Independent Audit & Benchmarking of Clinical Engineering Services

Effective Clinical Engineering programs encompass a broad range of activities focusing on healthcare technology.  With Strategic Health Care Technology Associates' (SHCTA) thorough knowledge of industry best practices, we can provide your organization with an evaluation of its clinical engineering program as it compares with other programs in organizations offering similar services and of similar size, complexity and capabilities. 

SHCTA can not only determine how the scope and quality of your organization's clinical engineering program ranks compared with similar programs, we can provide a plan to address any deficit areas and provide the metrics that will enable your organization to continuously monitor the program's future performance. 

The scope of clinical engineering services addressed by SHCTA includes:

bullet Strategic Planning
  • Capital

    • Evaluating existing and new technologies … including strengths and limitations in context of the intended applications

    • Identifying existing technologies that should be scheduled for replacement or upgrade due to obsolescence or condition

    • Planning for installation, integration with other medical & information systems

    • Contributing to cost-benefit, life-cycle cost, and ROI analyses

  • Services

    • Evaluating future need for services … adding services to meet developing needs and phasing out services for which there is little or no demonstrable benefit

    • Planning for transition from existing to future services (e.g., acquisition of skills, resources, education of clients & staff, implementation schedules)

bullet Acquisition
  • Assessing need for
    • new, beneficial technologies
    • replacing equipment due to condition, obsolescence, etc
  • Participating in Request for Proposal (RFP) preparation
  • Reviewing of proposals/bids and conducting technical evaluations
  • Preparing of life-cycle cost & ROI analyses and recommendations
  • Coordinating installation, incoming inspection and training (for users & service personnel)
bullet Inventory Management
  • Adopting a Standardized Nomenclature
  • Providing document trails regarding condition, use and servicing … including files for service reports (including 3rd party), hazard/recall reports, operator/service manuals (or their locations)
  • Preparing capital budgets & upgrades schedules
  • Standardizing on “best of breed”
  • Facilitating integration between devices & systems
  • Conducting risk analyses and facilitating risk mitigation efforts (including disaster planning)
  • Establishing real financial value of medical technology assets 
bullet Maintenance
Managing the medical equipment service process (regardless of who actually provides service)
  • Identifying medical devices that are to be part of the Equipment Management Program using criteria that address
    • criticality
    • function
    • physical risks associated with use
    • equipment incident (e.g., service history)
  • Scheduling maintenance \ facility rounds
    • inspection & PM only those devices that benefit from this service … and at a reasonable frequency
    • conducting inspection rounds when “spot checks” are more effective than specific device inspection & pm
  • Corrective maintenance
    • Identify best service resource (consider quality, timeliness & cost)
    • Monitor service process & document
  • Analyzing & evaluating maintenance data
    • Identifying “problem” devices/systems that may be candidates for replacement (i.e., excessive service calls)
    • Identifying inadequate/inappropriate service (i.e., excessive calls for same/similar problems)
    • Identifying need for user education (i.e., numerous service calls with no problem found or where damage caused by operator)
    • Identifying need for inspection & pm changes (i.e., calls that might have been avoided by more frequently scheduled inspection & pm)
    • Identifying need for less frequent or no scheduled maintenance (i.e., no problems found during routine inspections & pm)
bullet Medical device hazards & recall
  • Identifying sources of information (FDA Enforcement Reports, HD Alerts, etc)
  • Assigning responsibility, creating effective information flow and document process, findings and follow-up
bullet Education
Participating in the development of device user educational programs (new staff, new devices/systems, process improvement)
  • Clinical staff (e.g., device users)

    • General

      • When & how to obtain CE assistance (e.g., repair services)

      • Procedures for addressing incidents involving medical devices

      • General medical device safety … performing pre-use inspections & operational checks

    • Specific Device

      • General indications & contraindications for use

      • Operating procedure

      • Basic troubleshooting

      • Back-up plans in case of equipment failure or unavailability

  • Technical staff

    • Identify professional roles & levels of staff (CE, Sr BMET, BMET) along with associated responsibilities

    • Encourage professional development, continuing education, and professional certification for engineers & technicians and document

    • Document technology related continuing ed &  training for technicians

Incident investigation
Investigating/reviewing all “incidents” where medical technology either did cause or could have caused injury or compromised diagnosis/treatment:

  • Conduct Failure Mode Effect Analysis (FMEA) / Root Cause Analysis (RCA)

  • Recommending

    • Change in process, policy/procedure

    • Additional education

    • Change in technology

  • Reporting to Safety Committee, Risk Management, Quality Review

bullet Quality & Safety
  • Adopting a quality management system (e.g., ISO 9000, Six Sigma, Malcolm Baldridge, or similar) that will facilitate identifying:
    • performance criteria for technical systems and processes
    • target goals and objectives (benchmarks) associated with use of technology
    • methods for achieving those goals and objectives
    • techniques for measuring progress toward goals and objectives (e.g., metrics)
    • a process for analyzing and improving effectiveness of methods used to achieve goals and objectives
  • Implementing a risk management program including:
    • an assessment program that identifies risks by evaluating the implications of failure of technical systems and their related processes on patient health, patient/staff safety, and the financial well-being of the organization
    • a mitigation program that prioritizes identified risk and provides methods for reducing them to an acceptable level
    • providing root cause analysis (RCA), failure mode effect analysis (FMEA), investigation, and reporting support when technology and technical processes are involved in adverse outcomes or incidents
    • identifying contributing causes
    • proposing recommendations to prevent reoccurrence

e-mail inquiries

© SHCTA